A historic Hamptons saltbox home that predates the Declaration of Independence just hit the market in Sagaponack, NY, after undergoing a meticulous restoration that breathed new life into its 280-year-old bones—while carefully maintaining its original charm and character.
Originally built around 1750, nearly three decades before the first Independence Day celebrations were held, the three-bedroom dwelling sits on nearly an acre just a stone’s throw from Poxabogue Pond.
Today, the property still retains many of the design elements that were put in place nearly 300 years ago, all of which have been lovingly restored by the sellers in a “top-to-bottom” renovation that transformed the 2,200-square-foot interior.
“The restoration was just completed, so it’s super fresh,” says listing agent Adam Hofer of Douglas Elliman. “The sellers dissected the entire house. They took the original beams down, restored them, and put them back up. They literally did everything, and it is one of the best restorations I have ever seen.”
Aesthetically, the home maintains a timeless, fresh feel, with exposed beams, original fireplaces, and—of course—the original saltbox style; however, the sellers carried out a number of very modern upgrades that ensure the dwelling will continue to stand the test of time.
“They added more modern elements as well, but kept it super period correct,” Hofer says. “Now, it has zero headaches but all of the charm and is every bit of the original house.”
The “comprehensive, top-to-bottom renovation” also included upgraded electrical service, new plumbing, the installation of a high-efficiency HVAC system, and full soundproofing between floors.
All of the windows have also been restored—eliminating another potential hurdle for future owners.
Other custom interior finishes include period paneling, rebuilt mantels, built-ins, and designer lighting. A renovated kitchen has marble countertops, a farmhouse sink, and high-end appliances. The three full bathrooms have also been remodeled and now offer bespoke tilework.
A finished lower level boasts a guest bedroom, custom closets, and terra-cotta herringbone floors.
Thanks to these updates, the property is considered entirely turnkey—ready for a new owner to take over stewardship of a true historic gem, one of only a handful left standing in the area.
“It’s all about the finished product and this is a great opportunity,” the listing agent adds. “It allows you the chance to own a historic home with no question marks. You aren’t going to wonder ‘what did I get myself into’ with this home.”
While Hofer notes that the home is not on the National Register of Historic Places, it is one of 16 designated historic structures within the Village of Sagaponack.
Located on nearly 1 acre, which offers the possibility for future development, the spacious lot has been redesigned with new sod and extensive plantings, and it also features a 1,500-square-foot barn and an in-ground swimming pool.
Though the sellers did not make any significant changes to the barn, Hofer says the structure could well serve as the foundation for a detached guest house or entertainment space with additional bedrooms to accommodate more guests.
“The barn is huge, so you could take it down to the studs and renovate it to use as a garage, pool house, or for entertaining,” Hofer notes. “It was not part of the restoration process and is right next to the pool, so that’s really cool if you wanted to transform it into a pool house.”
Currently, the primary residence on the property features three bedrooms and three bathrooms, as well as a sizable kitchen, and an intimate living room with a cozy fireplace.
“Custom millwork, period paneling, rebuilt mantels, solid oak doors with brass rim locks, designer lighting, and unlacquered brass hardware create a rich, layered aesthetic,” the listing notes.
“The fully renovated kitchen features Michelangelo marble, a Shaw farmhouse sink, and premium appliances including Bertazzoni, Cooper Home, and Miele. Each bathroom has been rebuilt with bespoke tilework and Lefroy Brooks fixtures, blending luxury with historical authenticity.”
Hofer says the Sagaponack Village market is red hot right now.
“It’s one of the highest priced ZIP codes in the nation and is pretty centrally located, so it has a great feel to it,” he says. “We have had a lot of showings and every one of the buyers has been more different than the next.”
He believes the property is most likely going to be snapped up by someone with an appreciation for its history—explaining that he sees it as the perfect weekend or vacation home.
“I think the next owner will be someone who wants an old home, be in Sagaponack, and will likely use it as a secondary residence,” he shares.
Get real estate news in your inbox
