(Image credit: Getty Images)
Social Security claiming decisions are often described as “permanent,” and in most ways, they are. Once benefits begin, the rules governing reductions, delayed credits and spousal coordination leave little room for correction.
Yet this narrative misses an important truth: The Social Security Administration does provide two limited but powerful do-over opportunities that can allow claimants to change course when circumstances change or decisions were made too quickly.
Those two rules are withdrawal of an application and voluntary suspension. They are often misunderstood, frequently misapplied and sometimes overlooked entirely by consumers and professionals alike.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more – straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice – straight to your e-mail.
If used correctly, they can preserve long-term income, protect spouses and undo early claiming mistakes. If used incorrectly, they can create confusion, unexpected repayment obligations or lost benefits.
Understanding the differences between these rules, and when each is applicable, is essential to sound Social Security planning.
Rule No. 1: Withdrawing an application, the one-time reset button
The first do-over option, withdrawing or canceling an application, applies early in the claiming process. It allows someone who has already filed for Social Security to essentially erase that filing as though it never happened.
How it works. The withdrawal of application is available up to 12 months after a retirement or spousal benefit has been approved (the first month of entitlement).
The claimant must file a formal request with SSA and repay the money they and their family received, as well as money withheld for Medicare premiums, taxes and garnishments.
If any medical expenses were covered by Medicare Part A during this time, those will need to be repaid to Medicare as well, including any benefits paid to a spouse or dependent based on that record.
Once approved, the withdrawal wipes the slate clean. The claimant can later refile at a higher age, restoring eligibility for delayed retirement credits and higher lifetime benefits.
Key characteristics:
- Available only within 12 months of first entitlement
- All benefits must be repaid, including auxiliary benefits
- Can be used only once per lifetime
- Applies to retirement and spousal benefits (not survivor benefits)
When this rule is most useful. This rule is often used when someone claims early (because of job loss, fear that Social Security will “run out” or receiving incomplete advice, for example) and then realizes the long-term cost of early claiming. It can also be helpful when health, income or marital circumstances change soon after filing.
For example, a worker who claims at 62 but returns to high-earning employment months later may discover that the retirement earnings test is withholding benefits while permanently locking in a reduced benefit.
Withdrawing the application allows that person to step back, wait and later claim at a higher age.
Important cautions. Withdrawing an application is not free and is not automatic. Repayment can be substantial, and some claimants are surprised to learn that benefits paid to others, based on the claimant’s earnings record, must also be repaid.
Because the rule is available only once, using it casually or without a long-term plan can eliminate a valuable future option.
Rule No. 2: Voluntary suspension, pausing to earn more
The second do-over rule, voluntary suspension, operates very differently. It applies later in the claiming age timeline and does not erase a filing.
Instead, it allows someone who has already claimed benefits to pause payments and earn delayed retirement credits going forward.
How it works. Voluntary suspension is available only after reaching full retirement age (FRA). Once FRA is reached, a claimant who is already receiving retirement benefits may request that payments be suspended.
During the suspension period, benefits grow each month, at a rate of 8% per year until age 70, when delayed credits stop accruing.
Unlike withdrawal, there is no repayment requirement for past benefits already received.
Key characteristics:
- Available only at or after FRA
- No repayment of prior benefits
- Benefits resume automatically at age 70 (or earlier if requested)
- Delayed retirement credits are accrued during suspension
The post-2015 rule change. Before 2016, voluntary suspension could be used as a spousal coordination strategy, allowing a worker to suspend while a spouse continued collecting spousal benefits. Congress eliminated that strategy in 2015.
Today, when a worker suspends benefits, all auxiliary benefits on that record are also suspended, including spousal and child benefits. This makes voluntary suspension primarily an optimization tool for the individual, not the entire household.
When this rule is most useful. Voluntary suspension is most effective for individuals who:
- Claimed at FRA but later want to increase their benefit
- Continue working after claiming and no longer need the income
- Experience improved health or longevity expectations
For example, someone who files out of caution prior to FRA, but then realizes they can afford to wait, may suspend their benefits at FRA or later. They do not need to repay any benefits.
While suspended, their payment will accumulate delayed retirement credits up until age 70, when they then restart collecting.
Withdrawal vs suspension: A critical distinction
Although both rules provide flexibility, they are not interchangeable:
| Header Cell – Column 0 |
Withdrawal of application |
Voluntary suspension |
|---|---|---|
|
Timing |
Within 12 months of entitlement |
After full retirement age |
|
Repayment required |
Yes |
No |
|
Lifetime limit |
Once |
Multiple suspensions allowed |
|
Erases original filing |
Yes |
No |
|
Affects dependents |
Must repay |
Benefits are suspended |
Understanding which rule applies, and when, is essential to avoiding costly mistakes.
Why these rules matter more than ever
These two do-over rules exist because Congress and the SSA recognize that life happens. Beneficiaries’ health changes, employment resumes, spouses pass away and financial realities evolve.
The rules are narrow by design, but they provide meaningful protection for those who understand them.
For professionals advising clients, and for individuals making their own decisions, these provisions underscore a broader lesson: Social Security claiming is not just a filing event; it is an income planning strategy. Knowing when a do-over is available can be the difference between locking in regret and reclaiming opportunity.
