:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/GettyImages-2227539686-70d784de11d546f582f3258cf976b7cf.jpg "How To Choose a Cash-Back Rewards Card")
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/GettyImages-2227539686-70d784de11d546f582f3258cf976b7cf.jpg)
| Cash-Back Rewards Card Types | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Card Type | Reward Structure | Pros | Cons |
| Flat-rate cards | A single percentage of cash back on all purchases, regardless of type (e.g., 1.5% flat rate), that is automatically earned each billing cycle | Simple, predictable, and easy to track | No incentive to spend money in certain categories |
| Tiered cards | Higher percentages of cash back on specific fixed categories (e.g., 3% on groceries, 2% on gas, 1% on all other purchases) that are automatically earned each billing cycle | Higher rewards for common spending categories | May not get the best rewards on your most frequent purchases |
| Rotating category cards | A higher cash back percentage on select categories that change periodically (e.g. 5% cash back on groceries and dining in Q2, then 5% on travel and gas in Q3). Typically requires you to activate specific spending categories to earn rewards | Potentially high returns on certain purchases | Requires monitoring spending categories and activations |
Flat-rate cards are ideal for those who value simplicity, while tiered cards can earn you more rewards if your spending aligns with the higher-rate fixed categories. Rotating category cards can yield the highest amount of cash back, but are typically more complicated to manage, since they require you to manually check and activate your chosen spending categories.
Compare Earning Potential
Once you understand your typical monthly spending habits and the cash-back rewards card types, you can calculate and compare how much you could realistically earn in rewards.
Let’s say you consistently spend $1,000 per month on your credit card: $500 on groceries, $200 on gas, and $300 on other purchases.
- A 2% flat-rate card would earn $20 a month or $240 per year.
- A tiered card that offers 3% cash back on groceries, 2% on gas, and 1% on other purchases would earn $22 per month ($15 on groceries, $4 on gas, $3 on other purchases), or $264 per year.
- A rotating category card with 5% cash back could potentially earn you more than either a flat-rate or tiered card per month, depending on the maximum eligible purchase amounts. This is typically up to $1,500 per quarter in combined spending, with any additional purchases earning 1% cash back. Even if you only spent up to the 5% max, you would earn $25 per month or $300 per year. However, this maximum earning potential only applies if you max out your spending in the available categories each quarter (and remember to activate them).
Other Ways To Earn Rewards
In addition to the card’s main cash-back reward structure, many tiered card providers offer other limited-time, rotating rewards linked to certain retailers or spending categories. These deals are typically activation-based (not automatic) and only last for a few weeks or months at a time, but have the potential to maximize your earnings through a capped dollar amount or high cash-back percentage. Some examples might include:
- 5% cash back on dining at select restaurants.
- $10 cash back on one purchase from a specific online retailer.
- 10% cash back on a stay at select hotel chains.
- 15% cash back on any airline ticket purchase.
Some card providers also offer sign-up bonuses, which give you additional cash back if you meet minimum spending requirements during an initial period of time after you open your account. You may be able to add several hundred dollars to your total rewards in the first year this way.
Evaluate Fees and Features
Like other types of credit cards, some cash-back rewards cards may charge an annual fee to keep the account open. These fee-based cards are known for greater benefits and rewards, such as higher cash back percentages and travel perks, so it may be worth the expense if the benefits outweigh that annual cost. On the other hand, cards with no annual fee may offer a lower APR but fewer cardmember rewards.
Other factors to weigh include:
- Cash-back earning caps, which represent the maximum amount of cash you can earn on eligible purchases. Cards that offer higher cash-back percentages often have a lower earning limit.
- 0% or low-percentage introductory APR offers, which can help if you plan to make a large purchase upfront and pay it off over time
- Purchase protections or extended warranties that add value beyond rewards.
- Foreign transaction fees, which matter if you plan to use your card for travel abroad.
Warning
Don’t get swayed by a card’s highest advertised cash-back rate. Unless you’re confident your spending will hit those top-earning categories, a simpler no-fee card may give you better value overall.
Look at Redemption Options
Cash-back redemption methods vary by card, so the best choice for you depends on how you want to use your rewards. Common options include:
- Direct deposit into a bank account.
- Statement credit to reduce your card balance.
- Retail or dining gift cards.
- Travel/entertainment redemptions in the form of credits.
You’ll also want to consider the redemption thresholds for your chosen card. Some cards let you redeem rewards at any time with no minimum, while others require you to accumulate a certain amount before cashing out. Your card provider may even offer a combination of these policies—for instance, there’s no minimum accumulation if you want to redeem a statement credit, but gift cards can only be redeemed in amounts of $25 or more.
If you prefer the simplicity of cash in hand, look for a card that automatically redeems cash back for a direct deposit or statement credit at a certain threshold. If you prefer a greater variety of rewards, look for a card with plenty of redemption options and flexibility in how you can use your cash back.
Matching the Card to Your Lifestyle
The best cash-back card is the one that fits seamlessly into your daily life and aligns with your financial goals.
Best for Budgeters: Flat-Rate or Tiered Card
A flat-rate or predictable tiered card that rewards consistent spending habits can help you keep things simple and steady. Plus, you may be able to earn more rewards if you pay attention to the rotating limited-time deals offered by your card provider.
Best for Strategists: Rotating Category Cards or Multiple Cards With Different Reward Structures
If you’re willing to track spending categories and optimize your card usage for maximum return, consider a rotating category card with categories that already align with your spending habits. Depending on your credit score and ability to juggle multiple cards and payments, you might even consider a combination of cards to cover multiple areas of spending.
The choice ultimately comes down to how you spend and how much effort you’re willing to put in. A slightly lower flat-rate card that automatically rewards you may be more worth it in the long run than a complex system that requires consistent attention and maintenance. However, if you’re organized and strategic about your spending, you can earn more cash back on the things you buy every day.
Is It Better To Get a Flat-Rate or Category-Based Card?
This depends on your spending habits. Flat-rate cards work best if your expenses are spread evenly across categories. Category-based cards may yield higher returns if your card spending is concentrated in certain areas, like groceries or dining.
How Do I Calculate Which Card Gives Me the Most Rewards?
Estimate your monthly spending by category and multiply by each card’s reward rate(s) to determine how much you could earn each month (or year, if you multiply by 12). Subtract any annual fees to determine your net cash-back earnings.
Are Cash-Back Cards Worth It if I Don’t Spend Much?
Yes, especially if you choose a no-fee card. Even modest spending can yield rewards over time, and paying off your balance every billing cycle can help you build credit responsibly while earning your cash back.
The Bottom Line
A cash-back rewards card can be a valuable financial tool when it matches your lifestyle and helps you earn money back on everyday purchases. By understanding your spending habits, comparing card types and features, and choosing one that you can manage, you’ll maximize rewards without overcomplicating your finances.
