You don’t need to be a physicist to know that Sir Isaac Newton’s first law of motion is: “Objects at rest tend to stay at rest unless acted upon.”
This is Newton’s description of inertia — and it’s also a law referenced recently at the Center for Retirement Research, by research fellow, Geoffrey T. Sanzenbacher. Also a professor of economics at Boston College, Sanzenbacher unpacked recent research on how inertia can affect retirement savings efforts.
Ultimately, he found that inertia can both help and hurt your efforts in saving for your future — it all depends on the way you’re managing your accounts.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more – straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice – straight to your e-mail.
The ‘Newton rule’ shows that inertia can help you save for retirement
As the Center for Retirement Research explains, inertia can either work for you or against you. Because people tend to stick to the status quo, employers are trying to help workers by automating best practices, detailed below.
| Header Cell – Column 0 |
For You (Best Practices) |
Against You |
|---|---|---|
|
Scenario 1 |
Your employer auto-enrolls new workers in company 401(k) plans. |
You’re not auto-enrolled in a 401(k), and you don’t make the effort to enroll. |
|
Scenario 2 |
Your plan automatically increases contributions over time. |
You’re auto-enrolled in a 401(k) with a low contribution level, and you don’t make changes. |
|
Scenario 3 |
Your employer automatically enrolls plan participants in target date funds so their asset allocation adjusts appropriately over time. |
You’re auto-enrolled in a 401(k) with the wrong investments or you don’t choose target date funds. |
The key is for the default, or the easy option, to be the one that sets people up for success in retirement, rather than leaving them to fail.
If your employer has followed these best practices, you can probably sit back and relax. If not, well, read on, because maybe it’s in your interest to stay on the couch.
Inertia may help you avoid investing mistakes
The Center for Retirement Research also identified another way that inertia can help bolster your retirement savings. It saves people from their instinct to become overly conservative in their investments as they age and approach retirement.
Of course, becoming more risk-averse as you get nearer to your retirement years can be a good thing. You don’t want to have your entire portfolio in stocks (or equities) when you need to start making withdrawals in a year or two. That kind of asset allocation could backfire in the event of a market crash, forcing you to withdraw money at a bad time and lock in losses — a retirement fumble known as the sequence of returns risk.
However, research into how older savers view equity investing and whether they act upon their beliefs revealed that retirement savers often failed to properly gauge market risk. In a survey of U.S. adults aged 48 to 78 with $100,000 or more in investable assets, researchers found that these individuals were often overly pessimistic about the stock market. They would, in fact, choose a far more conservative portfolio than they should.
The chart below shows three commonly-recommended glide paths for target date funds for the 20 years before and after retirement: aggressive, moderate and conservative. “Glide paths” are set formulas for how a portfolio will gradually reduce the percentage of investments in stocks and increase the percentage of safer investments over time. Vertical lines show that investors want to invest in a lower percentage of stocks than the glide paths recommend, especially early in their careers.
(Image credit: Aubry, Jean-Pierre and Yimeng Yin. 2025. “Why Do Desired Stock Allocations Differ from Actual Holdings?” Issue in Brief 25-17. Chestnut Hill, MA: Center for Retirement Research at Boston College.)
As Sanzenbacher pointed out, if older investors followed their desired investment asset allocation plan based on their level of risk aversion, their investment mix would be below the most conservative recommended glide path. This is true even among pre-retirees who are relatively aggressive in their preferred investment strategy compared with older investors.
Sanzenbacher said that “If these savers acted like they said that they would like to, their pessimism would be causing them to give up valuable returns.”
The good news, however, is that most people don’t adjust their asset allocation to reflect their risk tolerance. In fact, while participants on the whole said they wanted 37% of their retirement assets in equities, the average they actually had invested was higher and was much closer to the recommended moderate glide path.
Pre-retirees, in other words, benefited by not adjusting their portfolios to their preferred asset allocation — and that’s most likely because of inertia. Since many of the plan participants were invested in target date funds, they stayed in those funds with the appropriate investment mix instead of switching to the more conservative investments they claimed they preferred.
A lack of action saved these investors from their own fear of the market and allowed them to remain appropriately invested.
Can — and should — you make inertia work for you?
Doing nothing can actually be helpful in many ways in retirement investing.
As mentioned above, if you set up large automatic 401(k) contributions early and make auto-increases the default, you’ll be more likely to hit your investment goals.
You’re also less likely to panic sell if the market starts to decline. And, since investing for the long-term is one of the best and most proven strategies for growing wealth, you’re probably more likely than very active investors to win in the market.
At the same time, a target date fund does come with higher fees than many other investments and isn’t necessarily as effective in helping you to achieve your retirement targets as a personalized plan would be.
Ultimately, it comes down to how confident you are that you can make the right moves, rather than acting based on fear, emotion, or short-term thinking.
If you are working with a financial planner or investment adviser to refine your goals, optimize your finances, and select the right investments, being more active in growing your retirement savings could leave you better off. If you’re acting on your own and making choices based on emotion, then inertia or inaction could serve you better.
So, before you decide whether to act upon your retirement savings, carefully consider whether the moves you’re making are better than no moves at all.
